Decline in Iraqi violence not accompanied by Sunni-Shiite reconciliation
November 21, 2007 8:02 am IraqLobe, Iraq: Toward National Reconciliation, or a Warlord State? AW, 11/21/07
While the vast majority of analysts agree that sectarian violence in Iraq has declined sharply from pre-”surge” levels one year ago, a major debate has broken out as to whether the achievement of the surge’s strategic objective – national reconciliation – is closer or more distant than ever.
On one side, advocates of the surge – the deployment beginning last February of some 30,000 additional troops to Iraq to help pacify Baghdad and al-Anbar province – claim that the counter-insurgency strategy overseen by Gen. David Petraeus has succeeded beyond their wildest dreams.
On the other side, surge skeptics argue that the strategy’s “ground-up” approach to pacification – buying off local insurgent and tribal groups with money and other support – may have set the stage for a much bigger and more violent civil war or partition, particularly as U.S. forces begin drawing down from their current high of about 175,000 beginning as early as next month.